Can ACH Positive Pay replace Check Positive Pay?
No. They stop different rails. Turning on ACH Positive Pay stops unauthorized electronic debits, while Check Positive Pay stops paper check alteration and counterfeit check stock.
While Check Positive Pay guards paper serial numbers before clearing, ACH Positive Pay (ACH Debit Filter) blocks or quarantines unauthorized electronic debits using NACHA Originating Company IDs, SEC codes, and maximum dollar thresholds.
Customize your pre-authorized NACHA Company IDs, SEC codes (`CCD`, `CTX`, `PPD`, `WEB`), and single-debit caps, then download as CSV or printable controller sign-off PDF.
| Company Name | 10-Char Company ID | SEC Code | Max Debit / Action | Control Notes | Remove |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Control Dimension | Check Positive Pay | ACH Positive Pay / Filter |
|---|---|---|
| Primary Threat Stopped (Check vs. ACH) | Check Positive Pay: Paper check washing, forged signatures, counterfeit check stock, stale/void presentments | ACH Positive Pay: Unauthorized electronic ACH debits using stolen routing & checking account numbers |
| Controller Daily Workflow | Export ERP check run -> Compile Fixed-Width/CSV -> Upload before check distribution; decide morning exceptions | One-time Allowlist setup per Company ID; review occasional unknown debit exceptions before bank deadline |
| File Format Dependency | High (strict bank byte offsets, implied cents, CRLF ASCII) | None for filtering (rules live in portal; exception returns use portal clicks) |
| Key Matching Attributes | Account #, Check Serial #, Dollar Amount, Issue Date, Payee Name (with OCR) | ACH Originating Company ID (10 chars), SEC Code (CCD/CTX/PPD), Max Dollar Limit |
Commercial checking accounts exposed to vendor payments face two completely different fraud vectors: paper check washing / counterfeit stock (defended by Check Positive Pay) and unauthorized electronic ACH pulls initiated using stolen routing + account numbers off an old check (defended by ACH Positive Pay).
Unlike Check Positive Pay, ACH Positive Pay does NOT require daily CSV or fixed-width issue uploads. Instead, controllers maintain a pre-authorized ACH Allowlist inside the bank treasury portal pairing each approved trading partner Company ID, SEC Code, and maximum authorized debit amount.
Every US commercial ACH debit carries a 3-letter Standard Entry Class (SEC) code identifying the transaction authorization format. Setting SEC-specific caps prevents a rogue vendor or misconfigured billing feed from sweeping your operating account.
Use Strict Per-Debit Dollar Ceilings
Even for legitimate payroll providers or state tax agencies, set an explicit Max Single Debit Cap inside your ACH Positive Pay filter so compromised credentials cannot over-draft your balance.
No. They stop different rails. Turning on ACH Positive Pay stops unauthorized electronic debits, while Check Positive Pay stops paper check alteration and counterfeit check stock.
Ask the vendor treasury contact for their 10-character NACHA Originating Company ID before their first debit, or inspect a prior settled ACH debit line on your bank statement / BAI2 file.